A Single Process Mass Spectrometer Solution for Quantitative Analysis in Refinery Flare Emissions Monitoring (40 CFR 60 Subpart Ja)
Chemical manufacturers and oil refineries are required to measure the component concentration of waste gas streams moving towards the flare according to new environmental regulations such as the EPA’s 40 CFR 60 subpart Ja. This EPA regulation mandates the analysis of Total Sulfur, hydrogen sulfide, and BTU content in the flare gas released from US refineries by November 2015.
Since flare streams consist of a range of components of varying concentrations, mass spectrometryis ideal for flare monitoring application, as it is capable of delivering real-time data on total sulfur, hydrogen sulfide, hydrocarbon content, and BTU of the sample.
Besides providing the Flare CEMS measurements mandated by Subpart Ja, mass spectrometrydelivers speciated hydrocarbon and sulfur data for root-cause analysis in the case of a reportable release.
This article discusses the use of an Extrel MAX300-IG process control mass spectrometer (Figure 1) to measure a range of simulated flare conditions. The MAX300-IG can perform quantitative analysis for a number of compounds at a concentration range of 100% down to 10ppb. The mass spectrometeruses a 19mm quadrupole mass filter for improved sample throughput, yielding long-term stability and high analysis repeatability.
Dynamic Range and Linearity of Hydrogen Sulfide
Different sulfur compounds down to ppm levels are typically present in flare gas waste streams, including hydrogen sulfide (H2S), carbonyl sulfide (COS), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and carbon disulfide (CS2). This experiment simulated a variety of potential plant conditions using blended gas bottles to demonstrate the accuracy and linearity of the MAX300-IGmeasurements for H2S (Figure 2) and Total Sulfur (Figure3).
The mass spectrometer employed a single point calibration which was recorded on the 1986ppm standard. It provided a speciated analysis for each sulfur component in the sample, and provides real-time calculation of total sulfur for reporting purposes. The dynamic range of the analyzer for all components is linear up to 100%.
The linearity of the MAX300-IG on the hydrogen sulfide in the sample ensures the accuracy of the single-point calibration across the entire dynamic range of the mass spectrometer. In addition, it facilitates an alternative validation procedure for hydrogen sulfide measurement by means of a low-level sulfur standard rather than expensive, unsafe, high-percent hydrogen sulfide blends.
Real-time Measurement of Total Sulfur and High Heating Value
As per 40 CFR 60 subpart Ja, total sulfur values need to be recorded and reported to the EPA in the event of discharge exceeding a stipulated limit, and the root-cause analysis of such discharge events needs to be performed. This can be done with the full, speciated analysis of each hydrocarbon and sulfur component, as a spike of a specific chemical is useful to determine the source of the emission and to facilitate reporting.
The MAX300-IG can also quantify the presence of non-sulfur components in a flare stream. It's highly accurate measurements of non-sulfur components help reporting BTU values with precision and reproducibility (Table 1). The instrument performs the real-time calculation and reporting of the BTU values to the plant control system, and records the speciated concentrations of each hydrocarbon. Monitoring each component across the full dynamic range (up to 100%) in the event of a release is crucial aspect for root-cause analysis.
Table 1. Speciated hydrocarbon measurements and calculated stream high heating value (HHV).
Instrument Range and Linearity Independent of Component
The MAX300-IG was integrated to a sample system consisting of a blend of hydrogen and carbon dioxide to demonstrate its entire dynamic range, and its linearity of response to different compounds. Here, H2S and CO2 were measured from 0-100% by altering the sample composition subsequent to a a single-point calibration (Figure 4).
In this flare gas application, the same equipment was used by the MAX300-IGfor the analysis of each component as it has only one sample path. Moreover, the physics of ion trajectories forms the basis of the separation principle in the case of a mass spectrometer. Hence, the accuracy and linearity of the mass spectrometeris independent of compound identity; this validates the instrument across the entire range by means of any high concentration standard, irrespective of chemical composition.
Dangerous high-concentration sulfur standards are normally used to validate compliance with regulations such as subpart Ja. However, validations can be done at the high range using safe-to-handle gases such as argon, nitrogen and carbon dioxide, thanks to the separation principle of the mass spectrometer. This allows the flare CEMS system to be installed and operated safely and cost effectively.
Sulfur Analysis Response Time and Hysteresis
The timely response of the instrument to stream changes is crucial in dynamic sample analysis. Hysteresis and clearing are the major problems while handling compounds such as H2S due to their reactivity with steel surfaces. The MAX300 is designed for the analysis of flares containing sulfur, and uses sulfur specific components for the sample path’s wetted surfaces. Figure 5 shows the fast response of the analyzer to a change from a 100% H2S sample to a 100% CO2 sample (<10 seconds).
Since subpart Ja has mandated total sulfur measurement within the 0-300ppm analysis range, even slight hysteresis in the instrument can affect the measurement accuracy significantly. Here, the nitrogen gas was used to dilute a sulfur blend to record the decreasing sulfur concentrations at different levels from 0 to 300ppm. Then, increasing sulfur concentrations were recorded by reducing the nitrogen flow. The results shown in Figure 6 illustrate the lack of hysteresis, and the true linearity of the MAX300measurements of both H2S and Total Sulfur.
The MAX300-IG can measure hydrogen sulfide, BTU content and Total Sulfur in flare gas simultaneously, offering the dynamic response, dynamic range, and speed of analysis demanded by regulations such as subpart Ja.
In addition, the mass spectrometeris capable of monitoring more than one flare without compromising the 15-minute reporting cycle. It can measure percent to ppb level changes, and is highly sensitive to varying sample compositions. Further, speciation of all compounds delivers essential data for root-cause analysis and the linearity of the MAX300-IG allows for two alternative validation strategies to reduce the risk by avoiding the use of unsafe and expensive high- concentration H2S standards.
Applications that Require High Resolving Power at Low Masses
High-resolving power at low masses is required in several critical applications in the industrial and academic sectors. These include the determination of hydrogen isotopes in the presence of helium such as 4He /D2as well as CO in the presence of nitrogen (N2). Only 0.0033 amu is the mass difference between D2 and 4He.
Quadrupole Mass Spectrometers
Many quadrupole mass spectrometer instruments that are commercially available in the market are not capable of resolving such closely isolated masses. Extrel has over five decades of expertise in quadrupole development and sophisticated manufacturing methods, and they are capable of showing routine, high resolution, high stability performance with the advanced MAX-50 quadrupole mass spectrometer, a 19 mm tri-filter mass filter equipped with 2.9 MHz RF electronics (Figure 1).
The MAX-50 can independently deal with a wide range of UHV applications like geochronology, TPD, and high resolution SIMS. When integrated with Extrel’s application matched VeraSpec HRQ gas analysis systems, the measurement field is expanded to cover a broad range of gas analysis applications up to atmospheric pressure. The high-resolution MAX-50 is part of the MAX-QMS Series of quadrupole instruments.
Figure 2 shows spectra that were determined using the traditional MAX-50production instruments containing 2.9 MHz electronics, 19 mm tri-filter mass filter, negative/positive ion pulse counting multiplier with conversion dynode, and axial electron impact ionizer with dual thoriated iridium filaments.
High Resolution Power at Low Masses
Analysis of Carbon, Nitrogen, Oxygen, Argon, and Sulfur isotopes are areas of interest in geochemistry. Figure 2 depicts the usual resolution performance determined at m/z=40 and shows the top end resolution. Systems developed by Extrel have a resolution of at least 3000 FWHM at 40 m/z. With careful tuning, users are able to push these limits.
The resolution performance for low masses is shown in Figure 3. The measurements were carried out in a UHV chamber, where a mixture of 10 ppm deuterium and 10 ppm UHP helium diluted in UHP argon was spiked to a pressure of 5 x 106 Torr and shows excellent properties like baseline separation and peak shape.
In high-resolution experiments, peak stability is debatably as significant as anything else. When analytes are separated, just a few thousandths of an amu apart, it is necessary to get an accurate reading of the mass position. N2(MW=28.019) and CO (MW=28.008) are one of the toughest pairs of compounds to examine at the same time. However, Extrel’s MAX-50 quadrupole instrument can separate and differentiate both peaks to over a 30% valley (Figure 4).
High-resolution QMS quadrupole systems from Extrel are also utilized in isotopic analysis. In addition to splitting D2and He, hydrogen isotopes arealso studied at nuclear research facilities. Figure 5 shows peaks of diatomic hydrogen and 4He, 3He, and D2.
Extrel provides exceptional capabilities for high-resolution, low mass analysis, abundance-sensitivity characteristics, and unique resolution and transmission, which are not seen in any other commercially available quadrupole mass spectrometers. Extrel’s MAX-50 instrument can be utilized as a probe based MS system, a turnkey standalone VeraSpec HRQ system, or can be integrated into any current VeraSpec system.
Industrial Process Mass Spectrometer
Whether you are using a quadrupole as a mass spectrometer analyzer,or to size select ions for your experiment, it is important to use the quadrupole that will give you the best results.
Extrel’s newest Quadrupole Power Supplies (QPS) deliver unrivalled long-term stability.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, February 27, 2017 - Extrel will be exhibiting at the 2017 PITTCON conference in Chicago, March 5th - 9th, booth 3917. The conference will act as the platform for the debut of Extrel’s newest laboratory gas analyzer, the MAX300-CAT.
What are the main parameters that need to be monitored for efficient bioreactor control?