Misery makes for strange bedfellows: hostile Earth pushes early Triassic mammal and amphibian to share den

Synchrotron imaging reveals odd couple: 250 million years ago, mammal forerunner and amphibian shared burrow.

Grenoble, 21 June 2013: Scientists from South Africa, Australia and France have discovered a world first association while scanning a 250 million year old fossilised burrow from the Karoo Basin of South Africa. The burrow revealed two unrelated vertebrate animals nestled together and fossilised after being trapped by a flash flood event. Facing harsh climatic conditions subsequent to the Permo-Triassic (P-T) mass extinction, the amphibian Broomistega and the mammal forerunner Thrinaxodon cohabited in a burrow. Scanning shows that the amphibian, which was suffering from broken ribs, crawled into a sleeping mammal’s shelter for protection. This research suggests that short periods of dormancy, called aestivation, in addition to burrowing behaviour, may have been a crucial adaptation that allowed mammal ancestors to survive the P-T extinction. The results of this research are published on 21 June 2013 in PLOS ONE.

The international team of scientists was led by Dr. Vincent Fernandez (Wits University and the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF)), in collaboration with Dr. Fernando Abdala, Dr. Kristian J. Carlson and Prof. Bruce S. Rubidge (Wits University); Dr. Della Collins Cook (Indiana University); Dr. Adam Yates (Museum of Central Australia) and Dr. Paul Tafforeau (ESRF).

After many impressive results obtained on fossils, synchrotron imaging has led to revived interest in the studies of the numerous fossilised burrows discovered in the Karoo Basin of South Africa and dated to 250 million years ago. The first attempt to investigate one of these burrow casts surprisingly revealed a world-first association of two unrelated animals.

The fossil was recovered from sedimentary rock strata in the Karoo Basin (South Africa). It dates from 250 million years ago, at the beginning of the Triassic Period. At that time, the ecosystem was recovering from the Permo-Triassic mass extinction that wiped out most of life on Earth. In the Pangea Supercontinent context, what is now South Africa was an enclave in the southern half called Gondwana.  It was the scene of pronounced climatic warming and increased seasonality marked by monsoonal rainfall. To survive this harsh environment, many animals, including mammal-like reptiles (mammal forerunners), developed a digging behaviour, attested by the numerous fossilised burrow casts discovered in the Karoo Basin. These casts have long been thought to enclose fossilised remains, triggering interest from palaeontologists. Early this year, an international group of scientists started to research the contents of these burrows using X-ray synchrotron computed microtomography.

Two burrow casts were selected from the collection at Wits to be scanned using the state-of-the-art facility at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF). Using the unique properties of the X-ray beam which enables non-destructive probing, the scan of the first burrow started to reveal the skull of a mammal-like reptile called Thrinaxodon, an animal previously reported in another burrow. As the scan progressed, the three-dimensional reconstruction displayed results beyond expectations: the mammal-like reptile was accompanied by an amphibian Broomistega, belonging to the extinct group of Temnospondyl. “While discovering the results we were amazed by the quality of the images”, recalls Vincent Fernandez, main author, “but the real excitement came when we discovered a second set of teeth completely different from that of the mammal-like reptile. It was really something else”.

Besides the pristine preservation of the two skeletons, the team focused on the reasons explaining such an unusual co-habitation. “Burrow-sharing by different species exists in the modern world”, says Fernandez, “but it corresponds to a specific pattern. For example, a small visitor is not going to disturb the host. A large visitor can be accepted by the host if it provides some help, like predator vigilance. But neither of these patterns corresponds to what we have discovered in this fossilised burrow”.

The scientists gathered all the information to try to reconstitute the events that led to this incredible fossil aggregation, testing scenarios one after another. "It’s a fascinating scientific question: what caused the association of these two organisms in the burrow?” says Dr. Kristian Carlson. “One of the more obvious possibilities is a predator-prey interaction, but we inspected both skeletons looking for tooth marks or other evidence implying predation, ultimately finding no support for one having attempted to feed on the other”.

 Dr. Della Collins Cook adds, “The consecutive broken ribs struck me as resulting from a single, massive trauma. The amphibian clearly survived the injury for some time because the fractures were healing, but it was surely quite handicapped”. Dr. Vincent Fernandez notes “This Broomistega is the first complete skeleton of this rare species that has been discovered. It tells us that this individual was a juvenile and mostly aquatic at that time of its life”.

The scientists eventually concluded that the amphibian crawled into the burrow in response to its poor physical condition but was not evicted by the mammal-like reptile.

Numerous Thrinaxodon specimens have been found in South Africa, many of them fossilised in a curled-up position. Dr. Fernando Abdala says “I have always been fascinated by the preservation of Thrinaxodon fossils in a curled-up position that show even tiny bones of the skeleton preserved. It’s as if they were peacefully resting in shelters at the time of death”. The shelters prevented disturbance of the skeletal remains from scavengers and weathering.

“We also think it might reflect a state of torpor called aestivation in response to aridity and absence of food resources".

Piecing all the clues together, the team finally elucidated the enigmatic association, concluding that “the mammal-like reptile, Thrinaxodon, was most probably aestivating in its burrow, a key adaptation response together with a burrowing behaviour which enabled our distant ancestors to survive the most dramatic mass extinction event. This state of torpor explains why the amphibian was not chased out of the burrow”, concludes Prof. Bruce Rubidge.

Both animals were finally entrapped in the burrow by a sudden flood and preserved together in the sediments for 250 million years. Dr Tafforeau says, “Thanks to the unique possibilities for high quality imaging of fossils developed during the last decade at the ESRF, these unique specimens remain untouched, protected by their mineral matrix. Who knows what kind of information we’ll be able to obtain from them in the future and which would have been completely lost if the specimen had been prepared out of its burrow cast?”


Synchrotron reveals Early Triassic odd couple: injured amphibian and aestivating therapsid share burrow, Vincent Fernandez, Fernando Abdala, Kristian J. Carlson, Della Collins Cook, Bruce S. Rubidge, Adam Yates, Paul Tafforeau, PLoS ONE 21 June 2013 http://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0064978

Scientist contact:

Vincent Fernandez, ESRF, vinfernand@gmail.com

Press officer contacts:

ESRF: Claus Habfast, Tel 33 666 662 384, claus.habfast@esrf.fr

University of Witwatersrand: Erna Van Wyk Tel 27 11 717 4023 or 27 (0) 82 399 6574, erna.vanwyk@wits.ac.za

What’s new

  • Jocelynchavy aerial esrf lr

    Four new beamlines get go ahead at the ESRF, opening new frontiers in X-ray science

    News | 28 Jun 2017

    Four new beamlines are to be built at the ESRF (The European Synchrotron, Grenoble, France), the world-leading synchrotron X-ray source, ensuring that Europe continues to lead the world in X-ray science. This major project will provide researchers with new tools to gain unprecedented understanding of the complex structure of materials and living matter.

  • Hmba lattice

    Dr Pantaleo Raimondi wins 2017 Gersh Budker prize

    News | 28 Mar 2017

    The European Physical Society Accelerator Group (EPS-AG) has awarded the ESRF’s Accelerator & Source Director, Dr. Pantaleo Raimondi, the 2017 Gersh Budker Prize, for his outstanding contribution to the accelerator field in the form of his “invention of the Hybrid Multi Bend Achromat (HMBA) lattice”,

  • The EIB finances the European synchrotron in Grenoble for 65M€

    News | 11 Dec 2015

    With innovation as a main priority in its support of programmes of excellence in fundamental and applied research, the European Investment Bank (EIB) has decided to support the project ESRF- Extremely Brilliant Source (ESRF-EBS) to the level of 65 million euros.

  • Magma

    Remnants of an ancient magma ocean in the deep Earth revealed

    News | 4 Nov 2015

    Scientists have revealed that silicate magmas, mainly composed of MgSiO3 are denser than the rocks of the lowermost mantle.

  • Esrf 450x252

    X-ray vision deciphers archaeological mystery

    News | 30 Oct 2015

    Synchrotron light has pierced the mysteries of a small 17th Century metallic box thanks to X-ray imaging techniques developed at the ESRF. Scientists were able to virtually reconstitute, in 3D and with astounding resolution, the inaccessible contents of the very fragile and badly damaged box.

Search all our content